DOC. TYPE		Meeting Report
TITLE		Report of a Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 34/WG 1 in Bellevue (Seattle), Washington, USA, 2009-09-15/16
SOURCE		WG 1 Convener [Dr. Alex BROWN]
PROJECT
STATUS		This document is circulated for consideration at the SC 34 Seattle Plenary, 2009-09-17.
ACTION ID		FYI
DUE DATE
DISTRIBUTION		P, O and L Members of ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 34 ; ISO/IEC JTC 1 Secretariat; ISO/IEC ITTF
ACCESS LEVEL		Open
ISSUE NO.		97
FILE	NAME SIZE (KB) PAGES	1285.htm   3

Secretariat ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 34 - IPSJ/ITSCJ (Information Processing Society of Japan/Information Technology Standards Commission of Japan)* Room 308-3, Kikai-Shinko-Kaikan Bldg., 3-5-8, Shiba-Koen, Minato-ku, Tokyo 105-0011 Japan *Standard Organization Accredited by JISC
Telephone: +81-3-3431-2808; Facsimile: +81-3-3431-2808; E-mail: kimura@itscj.ipsj.or.jp

== Report of a Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 34/WG 1 in Bellevue, WA, USA ==

The meeting opened at 2009-09-15 at 14:00 PDT

ATTENDANCE

----------

Alex BROWN (GB) WG 1 Convenor; Griffin Brown Digital Publishing Ltd

Francis CAVE (GB) * AHG 3 Convenor; Francis Cave Digital Publishing

Ken HOLMAN (CA) Crane Softwrights

Jirka KOSEK (CZ) ** Consultant

MURATA Makoto (JP) WG4 Convenor; International University of Japan

Mohamed ZERGAOUI (FR) Innovimax

Yushi KOMANCHI (JP) WG2 Convenor; Osaka Institute of Technology

(* = 2009-09-16 only)

(** = remote participation)

AGENDA AS ADOPTED

-----------------

1. Opening - 2009-09-15 14:00

2. Adoption of the Agenda

3. Future meeting schedule

4. Review of action items from Prague meeting

Document: N 1191

5. 19757-5

Document: N 1211

6. Proposed new Part 6 of DSDL

7. Part 11 of DSDL

8. Other parts of DSDL

9. TR 9573-11

10. 26300 (in conjunction with AHG 3)

Document: N 1221

11. Approval of Recommendations

12. Any other business

13. Closing.

RECOMMENDATIONS TO SC 34

------------------------

WG 1 recommends that SC 34 adopt the following resolutions:

# SC 34 accepts the resignation of Murata MAKOTO as editor of 19757-1 and appoints Alex BROWN in his place.

# SC 34 approves that this project is progressed to FDIS. SC 34 instructs its project editor to prepare a revised text for FDIS processing.

# SC 34 creates a project subdivision for a revision of ISO/IEC 19757-3 per Document N 1287. SC 34 instructs its Secretariat to initiate a 3-month CD ballot when a text is submitted by Project editor.

# SC 34 approves the following Liaison Statement and instructs its Secretariat to forward it to ITSIG:

----------------------

Informal Liaison to ITSIG from SC34

SC34/WG1 had developed ISO/IEC TR 9573-11 2nd edition "Structure descriptions and style specifications for standards document interchange", with support of ISO Central Secretariat. It specifies:

• standards document structure using SGML/DTD, XML/DTD and RELAX NG

• style specification using XSL-FO and DSSSL fully conforming to the ISO/IEC directives part2, and specifies

• XSLT specification for preview of XML instances.

After the publication (2004-04) of the TR, SC34 established a project of Amd.1 to ISO/IEC TR 9573-11 2nd edition to satisfy the project editors' requirements.

After the approved PDAM ballot, the project is developing FDAM text.

The Amd.1 is a subset of ISO/IEC TR 9573-11 2nd edition and specifies:

• document structure (using RELAX NG) that authors or editors interest in

• its style specification (using XSL-FO) and

• XSLT specification for preview of XML instances.

Responding to some requests, the PDAM text was distributed to ITU-T/TSAG members and IEC/TC100/AGM members for their review, as shown in T05-TSAG-C-0049 and T05-TSAG-R-0025. SC34 believes that it is a good opportunity to develop a common document structure and style specification for authors/editors in ISO, IEC and ITU-T.

SC34 notes the activities of ITSIG on an office software-based XML template and believes that the Amd. will be able to satisfy the requirements of some authors or editors even after the completion of ITSIG XML template. In order to avoid future confusion of authors or editors, SC34 would like to maintain an informal liaison with ITSIG group on these topics. This will give both groups the opportunity to evaluate

the other's work in this area to avoid duplication of effort and to collaborate on interoperable deliverables.
----------------------

# SC 34 approves the following Liaison Statement and instructs its Secretariat to forward it to W3C:

"SC 34 is pleased to note that W3C and SC 34/WG 1 will be cooperating in the production of 19757-11 (“Schema Association”) and looks forward to the results of this work.”

# SC 34 approves the following Liaison Statement and instructs its Secretariat to forward it to W3C:

"SC 34 notes that W3C has forwarded the XForms 1.1 schemas, which use 19757-2, to SC 34/WG 1 for comment. SC 34 understands WG 1 will forward its comments to W3C after its Paris meeting on 2009-11-30. SC 34 expresses its willingness to review any schemas written in DSDL languages, including RELAX NG."

ACTION ITEMS

------------

# Alex BROWN to prepare a Disposition of Comments in response to N1211, and prepare an FDIS text for 19757-5 taking this into account

# Alex BROWN to investigate whether SWG ARM can provide facilities for hosting its web sites and email lists

# Francis CAVE to produce a DCOR for 19757-8 in response to comments received, and forward it to the convenor for processing

# Ken HOLMAN and Mohamed ZERGAOUI to produce a draft for a possible new Part 6 of 19757, addressing cross-referencing validation.

# WG 1 convenor to issue meeting notices for teleconferences and to investigate what communication methods will be most effective.

# Yushi KOMANCHI to produce a Disposition of Comments in response to N0000 and send it to the WG 1 convenor for processing

# Mohamed ZERGAOUI to ask W3C who their appointed liaison officer to SC 34 is, and to investigate how work of 19757-11 may be jointly progressed between W3C and SC 34.

# MURATA Makoto and Jirka KOSEK to review the W3C RELAX NG schemas for XForms 1.1, and report their findings to the Paris meeting.

FUTURE MEETINGS

---------------

The next meeting of WG 1 will be 2009-11-30 in Paris, France.

ACCLAMATIONS

------------

WG 1 expresses its thanks to the US National Body for the invitation to Bellevue and for the provision of excellent meeting facilities.

WG 1 expresses its thanks to Microsoft for providing entertainment.